CBS Ratings Race: Is The Mentalist Doing Well? Will It Be Cancelled?

The Mentalist to be cancelled?This season, CBS moved The Mentalist from Thursdays to Sunday nights, into (cancelled) CSI: Miami’s former timeslot. This move understandably made fans very nervous.

The Mentalist’s ratings have taken a serious hit this season. The premiere represented one of the worst showings in the series’ history and the numbers for subsequent episodes have dropped even lower.

CBS will surely take football over-runs into consideration when considering the show’s fate but it’s worth noting that CSI: Miami’s ratings were also impacted by football — and performed better. In its last season, Miami averaged a 2.1 rating with 9.85 million. That’s significantly better than The Mentalist’s current season average below.

What do you think? Will The Mentalist be cancelled this season? Share your comments below.

Here are the CBS season averages as of Thursday, November 8, 2012:

CBS scripted
TV shows
18-49 demo
rating (actual)
in millions
The Big Bang Theory 4.9 (4.93) 15.60 season 6 ratings
Two and a Half Men 3.7 (3.70) 12.78 season 10 ratings
NCIS 3.6 (3.56) 18.89 season 10 ratings
2 Broke Girls 3.4 (3.44) 9.42 season 2 ratings
How I Met Your Mother 3.2 (3.20) 8.00 season 8 ratings
Criminal Minds 3.0 (3.03) 11.79 season 8 ratings
NCIS: Los Angeles 3.0 (3.02) 15.93 season 4 ratings
Mike & Molly 2.9 (2.92) 8.90 season 3 ratings
Person of Interest 2.9 (2.90) 14.23 season 2 ratings
Elementary 2.5 (2.45) 11.19 season 1 ratings
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation 2.4 (2.42) 10.55 season 13 ratings
Partners 2.1 (2.12) 5.96 season 1 ratings
Vegas 2.0 (1.96) 12.06 season 1 ratings
Hawaii Five-0 2.0 (1.96) 8.13 season 3 ratings
The Mentalist 1.8 (1.82) 9.70 season 5 ratings
The Good Wife 1.8 (1.76) 9.59 season 4 ratings
Blue Bloods 1.4 (1.37) 10.65 season 3 ratings
CSI: NY 1.4 (1.35) 9.44 season 9 ratings
Made in Jersey (cancelled) 1.0 (0.95) 7.30 season 1 ratings
CBS non-scripted
TV shows
18-49 demo
rating (actual)
in millions
Survivor: Philippines 2.9 (2.88) 10.34 cycle 25 ratings
60 Minutes 2.7 (2.67) 13.73 season 45 ratings
The Amazing Race 2.6 (2.57) 9.55 cycle 21 ratings
Undercover Boss 1.5 (1.50) 7.96 season 4 ratings
48 Hours 1.0 (0.96) 4.67 season 26 ratings

These charts incorporate the daily final CBS show ratings (reported by Nielsen) and are sorted by the 18-49 demographic. Network advertisers typically prize those viewers most and so will pay more to reach them. There’s lots of information that the networks take into consideration when cancelling or renewing a TV series but the ratings are the biggest factor. The higher the ratings, the better chance that the show will be renewed. And yes, they take it into account when a show airs on a Friday or Saturday night.

For the status of your favorite CBS shows, check out this page.

Want more posts like this? Here are the other networks: ABC | The CW | FOX | NBC

Canceled and renewed TV show

46 Comments · Read them below or add one

  1. Bal says

    I really enjoy The Mentalist. It is a brilliant show, with great character development. I don’t think CBS should cancel it – it is in a tough spot on Sunday nights, but we on the west coast are not as affected by that. It is one of the most unique story lines I’ve seen – we’ve got to let it finish with grace!

  2. Ben says

    The Mentalist jumped the shark at the end of season 3 and has been treading water ever since. I hope this is the last season and the Red John story is finally wrapped up.

  3. Ford says

    If CBS cancels the show after moving it then I will cancel my viewing of CBS. Other than football, I don’t watch CBS shows anyway. But moving it to the worst spot on the calendar is basically saying F U to its fans.

  4. Mentalistphann says

    NOBODY knew the show was moving to Sunday nights. If you like this show, but have children, its really difficult to get to watch it, and try to get going for the school week. At least on Thursday, it was okay because the kids lightest day is Friday, so not as much to do for them. Gave me much better opportunity to watch. CBS truly picked the worst night of the week to drop a GREAT show with a truly unique character in Patrick Jane. I love the current storyline, but if CBS wants this show to hit it’s stride, like a, “24” did with its unique character in Jack Bauer, then they better move it to an easier night of the week.

    • Ford says

      I cannot even DVR it without starting at 10pm and ending at 12 pm. That is ridiculous. They basically cancelled the show after last season, but allowed it one more year to end the Red John case. In fact, I would not be surprised if the end of season 3 (for which I read that CBS was not happy) contributed to a negative feeling at CBS.

      No show, no CBS. Fans should write to CBS before it is too late and tell them the same thing:

  5. John says

    I’ve everyday airing of The Mentalist since season 1 in 2008. Please don’t cancel the show it’s been a long journey and we are ever so close to catching the elusive serial killer, Red John.

  6. says

    The Mentalist is my favorite show and the only show I watch regularly. I’m already angry at CBS for moving it to Sunday night so if they cancel it this soon I may never watch CBS again. I hope it goes for two or three more years at least. The storylines, the cast, the writers, everything is amazing. Please keep it on!

  7. Georgia says

    ONE OF MY FAVORITE SHOWS — PLEASE KEEP IT ON! I’d follow this show to any night that it’s on. Personally, I like it being on after the Good Wife. Both are great shows!

  8. primetimeblabber says

    CSI NY should have been the one cancelled…..CSI Miami had better ratings….CSI NY has seen bad ratings this season….I do not see CSI NY being renewed….

  9. Tlh45 says

    I have watched a couple of episodes this season and honestly can’t say that I enjoyed them. I have lost interest in it. Even Hawaii Five O rarely has a decent episode. I like Criminal Minds and CSI NY. I hope the keep them.

  10. Weng says

    Would be crazy if they do allow it to be cancelled. One of the most entertaining shows with a trully excellent cast. Every character is marvelously built and the chemistry is amazing. The plot with Red John is getting hotter and it is very promising!

  11. Tajoe77 says

    I truly hope it doesn’t get cancelled:( Love this show and watch every Sunday since it started its season:) Keep it on!!!

Leave a Comment

Your comment may need approval from a moderator before it appears. We review comments to weed out spam, duplicate postings and personal attacks. We welcome constructive discussion.