Detroit 1-8-7: New ABC Cop Series; Cancel or Keep It?

Detroit 1-8-7ABC has unveiled yet another cop series, Detroit 1-8-7. This one stars Michael Imperioli who, as you may recall, co-starred on ABC’s Life on Mars a couple seasons ago. That one was cancelled after 17 episodes. Will his new show last any longer?

Detroit 1-8-7 follows a group of homicide detectives working on the tough streets of Detroit, Michigan. The ABC series stars Imperioli as well as Aisha Hinds, D.J. Cotrona, Erin Cummings, James McDaniel, Jon Michael Hill, Natalie Martinez, and Shaun Majumder.

In its premiere, the series attracted a lackluster 2.3 rating in the 18-49 demographic and 9.342 million total viewers. For the timeslot, it was in third (last) place for the all-important demo and in second place for total viewers (beating Parenthood).

What do you think of Detroit 1-8-7?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

The series premiere lost nearly half of its lead-in audience from Dancing with the Stars. Not good.

TV show supportOn top of that, Detroit 1-8-7 continued to lose viewers as the hour progressed. That’s a pretty good indicator that those viewers won’t be back next week.

Detroit 1-8-7 will likely lose viewers in week two, as most shows do. It won’t have to lose many to be in serious trouble.

But, what do you think? Is Detroit 1-8-7 worth watching? Will you make a point to tune in or should it be cancelled already?

Canceled and renewed TV show

111 Comments · Read them below or add one

  1. stormy says

    I’m so tired of all the good shows getting cancelled just because some idiot puts it up against a program like “dancing with the stars” . There is no program, new, old or otherwise that will show well against one of the most watched shows on TV today. Detroit 1-8-7 is a very realistic, and gritty show. It’s about time somone has brought attention to life in Detroit and the hardships of those that live there and what they have to face on a daily basis. It’s damn HARD. The city is full of poverty and crime and there needs to be a show like this to bring peoples attention to it. People seem to love reality shows until the reality gets too REAL, or is that just the networks take on things. If it is’nt FLUFF, SEX, or FANTASY they don’t want to give these shows a fair shake. It’s people like that , that made Detroit Mi. the poverty stricken and depressed area it is today. What do ya wanna bet these network geniuses are all driving honda’s, toyota’s, volkwagons, mercedes, and audi’s etc. Is’nt it time to step up to the plate people and take a little responsability, buy an american made car. You won’t just be helping Detroit but the entire country and Detroit 1-8-7 if given the right night and time slot could very easily be one of the top rated TV drama’s. I for one have had enough of the garbage TV programming you force feed us. Get it right this time, would you please?

  2. Craig Storteboom says

    Hey Nick, Quebec borders Ontario. Only ONE of the Canadians was speaking French, there are immigrants from all over the world living in Ontario. Just as many if not more so than any other North American region. Cobo Hall is called Cobo Arena ALL THE TIME. I lived there for 35 years. Life insurance DOES NOT always pay on suicide. In fact, if the insurance company investigators, or police report PROVE it was suicide, most often they won’t. I know alot of whites that live in Detroit. If you don’t like the show, turn the channel. But don’t think you know it all… obviously, you don’t.

  3. Ed Westlakle says

    Hey the show is great, don’t cancel it. I get tired of just watching the news because there aren’t any good guy shows on.

  4. Linda Fabrizio says

    I don’t watch cop shows and only tuned in as a curiosity because it was shot in Detroi,t bu,t WOW, was I blown away!! The acting is top notch, the storys are interesting and realistic. After the first time time to check it out I can’t miss one show.
    Please we don’t need any more shows with whinning women, how boring.

  5. Nick says

    This is a STUPID show. Someone needs to tell the writers and producers that guns need triggers, people in Ontario don’t speak French, Michigan does NOT have the death penalty, noone’s ever called Cobo Hall “Cobo” Arena, life insurance does pay on suicide, and there are about 12 white people that live in Detroit (6 downtown, and 6 homeless crackheads). What’s next? Perhaps they’ll say that people from Pontiac can fly. Maybe Detroit Fire stations make their trucks out of gummi worms. Just STUPID.

  6. Tim says

    I really hope that Detroit 187 is back for another season.
    The show is great, and its developing characters week to week.
    It would be a shame to introduce new plot the gangster from New York who contacted Fitch,..and then pull the plug on the show.
    I look forward to Tues. evenings and REALLY want this great show to survive.

  7. Anonymous says

    Please don’t cancel this show. I think that Detroit makes a great setting for a cop show. I think that each episode is getting better and better. It’s gritty and raw. Give it a chance!

  8. says

    DETROIT 187 SHOULD STAY …. NOT THE GOOD WIFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    Dodge Saienni

  9. zana says

    Finally there is character and plot development for Detroit 187. The D is shown with at least some compassion, grit and drive to make the city better. Keep Detroit 187 running for at least a second season. The positive light and many jobs it has created adds a lot of soul to the city.

  10. Anonymous says

    This is a great show . My wife and I love it please do not cancel this show. I am sure that most people who watch this show do not watch Dancing With The Stars.

  11. Anonymous says

    Detroit 187 is a great show. I love the characters and the stories. Maybe ABC can move it to another night. There are so many other bad shows on tv that make it, I don’t understand how well-done shows get canceled.

  12. Gary Tillinghast says

    Detroit 1-8-7 is my favorite show this year. I never miss it, and really hope it stays.
    I visited Detroit in 2010 and now really enjoy all the locations shots even more: Burned-out houses, abandoned buildings, etc. Nothing Hollywood about it. Very real, great story lines, and terrific cast. Keep this one! Please…

Leave a Comment

Your comment may need approval from a moderator before it appears. We review comments to weed out spam, duplicate postings and personal attacks. We welcome constructive discussion.