The Client List: Season Three Renewal in Jeopardy

Client List season 3 or canceled?While season two of The Client List didn’t perform as well as the first year, the ratings aren’t what could cause the Lifetime show to be cancelled.

Featuring the talents of Jennifer Love Hewitt, Colin Egglesfield, Loretta Devine and Cybill Shepherd, the second season of The Client List averaged 2.06 million viewers with a 0.8 rating in the 18-49 demographic. That’s down from year one’s 2.51 million and 0.9 demo rating.

According to Deadline, the third season renewal is being held up because Lifetime and the producers are trying to figure out how to handle Hewitt’s real-life pregnancy. The actress is more than three months along.

Hewitt, who is also an executive producer on The Client List, wants her real-life fiancé Brian Hallisay to be the fictional baby’s dad as well. Playing Kyle Parks, Hallisay started as a recurring performer but then became a series regular.

This demand is at odds with the plans of Client List’s showrunner who wants Colin Egglesfield’s character (Evan Parks) to be the dad. Lifetime hasn’t made a decision yet but reportedly doesn’t want Hallisay.

Supposedly both sides are willing to walk away over this disagreement but a representative for Hewitt said, “There are many story lines we are exploring… So any suggestion that we are not doing our best to develop a great season is simply not accurate.”

What do you think? Which character should be the baby daddy? Do you think the series should be cancelled or renewed for a third season?

Canceled and renewed TV show

91 Comments · Read them below or add one

  1. Julie says

    Please bring back The Client list, really want to see what happens nxt after the fire at The Rub etc. This show is exciting, and I think that Kyle should be the dad as he is in real life. I know you will figure it out, Jennfier is a truly beautiful and amazing actress!

  2. michele says

    Don’t cancel pleassssssse. I want Evan to be the daddy, because the sparks fly when they
    Are together. But since nothing happened between the two. The daddy has to be the guy
    That paid her to do the deed. Don’t cancel!!!!!!!

  3. Tiffani says

    I would like to see a 3rd season premier! I live with my parents and my mom and I both watch this show. We record the show regularly on the DVR to watch it later because we have lives that do have to continue and can’t be dedicated to the t.v. Every time we want to watch a show. As for the baby scenario if you want drama go with Colin being the father because that really will stir up a lot of issues between the brothers. If you want a little drama go with Brian. I personally think you should go with Colin being the father only because I think it may bring more viewers to watch the show.

  4. Valerie says

    Please do not cancel this show!!! I watch it religiously and couldn’t bare to not have this show to look forward to. All we have are some really bad reality shows on lately and when this show came on I was so happy! Honestly at first I thought that Riley could have been a surrogate for Lacey and Dale-but now I saw some of the comments that the rich guy should be the father…that might be an even more interesting dramatic turn-lol. But because I love Riley so much and just love how her relationship with Kyle is going…and I think that it would be perfect for season 3. There is enough drama to unfold than to have to throw any more dramatic issues her way! I this it’ll be over kill. Soften the edges a little bit and give her more of a normal life for a change…add some drama in one of the other charachters. Poor Riley has been to hell and back so much already!

  5. Toni says

    I like the idea mentioned above that she be the surrogate for her good friend since she was responsible for the loss of the baby. If that is not juicy enough I think it should be the man she slept with for money. Adds a nice twist.

  6. T Crow says

    Why don’t they say she is a saragate for her friend who lost her baby. That way her husband not her brother in law is the father. This way she is pregnant on the show and helping her friend.

  7. Country girl says

    Don’t cancel!! I’m in suspense for the next season! I enjoy watching the show and can’t wait for season three! I am torn between who the baby’s daddy should be. I love Evan and think he should get rid of that girl he’s with now. I also think Kyle could really bounce back as a dad. It would definitely make things interesting if it were Evan’s but then they will have to sleep with each other for that!! Please bring back the show!!

  8. Karina says

    Have a miscarriage when they are about to do a DNA test, she is distraught yet slightly happy, we find out she alredy had a test before and kyle wasnt the father, leaving the $50k client the father. Having a another child will do nothing for the show so remove it. #doNotCancelTheShow!!

  9. casey says

    Please don’t cancel the show. its some thing that shows what real Texas women will go to for their family. Being from Texas myself and only 30 mins for Sugarland that’s how it is here. But I think her husband should be the daddy. I love the way they are together.

  10. Sandy says

    Please don’t cancel the show!!!!!’ I love it. I think Evan should be the father!!! I love their chemistry together on screen. There is always that doubt of whether they did or didn’t sleep together. I think the show is dynamite!

  11. Sandy says

    Please DO NOT CANCEL THE SHOW! I think Evan should be the father of Jennifer Love Hewitt’s character’s baby. I just love their chemistry on screen!!! The show is dynamite!!!!!

  12. LINNIE ZINNA says

    please don’t cancel the show!!!!! I agree with KERRI above through a wrench in the works and let that man she slept with be the daddy. LOL
    I love this show! It shows that as a person and mother you make decisions you normally wouldn’t make unless your family is on the line. love it love it love it

  13. Kerri says

    Please don’t cancel the show!!!!!’ I love it. I don’t think Kyle or Evan would be the father!!! She never slept with Evan so it couldn’t be his!!! I say the man she slept with for the money should be the daddy!!!

Leave a Comment

Your comment may need approval from a moderator before it appears. We review comments to weed out spam, duplicate postings and personal attacks. We welcome constructive discussion.