the forgotten: Disappointing Ratings for Christian Slater; Cancel It or Keep It?

the forgottenWhen Christian Slater’s TV series, My Own Worst Enemy, was cancelled last year it seemed a bit unlikely that the actor would return to the medium any time soon. Some film stars have made the journey to television in the past and, when the shows failed, they haven’t been too quick to return. But Slater hopped right back into the fray and has a new show for ABC, the forgotten. So, will this one stick around longer than the last one?

the forgotten revolves around a group of dedicated civilians that form The Forgotten Network. Led by Alex Donovan (Slater), the team donates its time to identify unrecognizable murder victims, trying to “give back the name of the deceased.” The show also stars Michelle Borth, Heather Stephens, Bob Stephenson, Anthony Carrigan, and Rochelle Aytes.

With a title that just invites snarky headlines, forgotten was skewered by many critics before the show even debuted. By and large, most viewers weren’t all that impressed either.

The series debuted on September 22nd to a decent 9.53 million viewers and a 2.6/7 rating/share among adults 18-49. While those numbers seem pretty good, upon closer examination, they aren’t all that positive.

Should the forgotten be cancelled?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

the forgotten’s lead-in, the very popular Dancing with the Stars, scored 16.28 million and a 3.9/10 in its last half hour. The first half hour of forgotten attracted only 10.14 million and a 2.7/7. That means that the Slater drama lost over 40% of its total lead-in audience and 33% in the demographic. What’s more, 12% of people who started watching forgotten turned it off half way through the premiere. That’s a sure sign that those people wouldn’t be back the next week.

And they didn’t return. In week two, the forgotten’s numbers dropped by more than 1.8 million viewers to 7.72 million. In the all-important demographic, the show’s ratings dropped from a 2.6/7 to a 2.0/5, a loss of 23%.

TV show supportAs of last night, things seem to have evened off a bit. For week three, forgotten attracted 7.81 million viewers and a 2.0/6. Though it’s positive that the ratings didn’t drop for a second time, these numbers are not healthy. forgotten ranked in a distant second place for total viewers (beating the under-performing Jay Leno Show) and third place for the demo (almost tying Leno).

Unless these numbers turn around, the forgotten’s days on the schedule are certainly numbered. ABC ordered 13 episodes to start and could pull the show or prematurely cut production. But, even if all 13 are finished and aired, it’s highly unlikely that ABC will order any more.

What do you think? Is this show worth watching or is it best left forgotten (sorry, too hard to resist)? Would you cancel it or keep it?

Canceled and renewed TV show

77 Comments · Read them below or add one

  1. Dana says

    The Forgotten has been getting better and better each episode! I’ve just read on other sites that the show is cancelled … I think ABC is making a mistake! They don’t give anything enough time for people to catch on and show their loyalty.

  2. Sara says

    I say they better keep the forgotten everytime they come out with something good to watch they never give it enough time and this show is really starting to get really good.

  3. Marcia Obillo says

    I hope this show continues. It’s great. It’s brought to light all the “forgotten” people out there. The chemistry among the characters is also great.

  4. Jenn says

    I like this show! They just need to give it some more time to catch on. Advertise for it a little and you’ll see, people will not forget to watch The Forgotten!

  5. Karen says

    Keep it! With so many “reality” shows on TV, it’s great to have a one-hour drama added to the mix. It’s time to stop the surge of non-scripted shows and go back to writers telling stories!

  6. Becca says

    Why don’t they try changing days or time slots before they just up and cancel a show? I love this show and if I can’t watch it, I alwauys make sure to record it! I am getting tired of getting attached to a show only to have it cancelled… and it seems to be ABC doing this more than the other networks!

  7. migrus says

    This is the most unique story idea to come along in a very tired genre. And ABC can’t let it find an audience? Time to turn the TV off.

  8. debbie says

    I think it’s a great show, if the raitings are slow in that day and time slot, move it don’t cancel it. Give it a chance.

  9. Rebecca says

    They better keep it its one of the best Tv Shows I have seen in a long time I would be rely depressed if they don’t keep the forgotten..

  10. jane says

    why do all the original ideas get cancelled in favor of tiresome reality shows and repeated ideas (ie., Law & Order after Law & Order)? Give the viewers a chance to become invested in the program. Seinfeld wasn’t a hit it’s first season either. This is a really good show.

Leave a Comment

Your comment may need approval from a moderator before it appears. We review comments to weed out spam, duplicate postings and personal attacks. We welcome constructive discussion.