The Playboy Club: Is the New NBC TV Show Worth Watching? ‎

Playboy Club tv seriesIt’s the fall season so NBC is once again trying to find a successful drama for the Mondays at 10pm timeslot. They had moderate success with Harry’s Law last season but opted to shift the Kathy Bates legal drama to Wednesdays.

Their newest entry, The Playboy Club, tries to capture the look of AMC’s Mad Men and apparently they’re hoping that sexy Playboy Bunnies are enough to get viewers to skip Castle and Hawaii Five-0.

The TV series takes place in the 1960s in Chicago. The Playboy Club is home to $1.50 cocktails, music, glitter and the beautiful Bunnies. One of the town’s top attorneys, Nick Dalton (Eddie Cibrian), is a frequent visitor and has mysterious ties to the mob. He comes to the aid of a new bunny (Amber Heard) who accidentally kills the patriarch of a prominent crime family. Others in the cast include Naturi Naughton, Laura Benanti, David Krumholtz, Leah Renee, Jenna Dewan, and Wes Ramsey.

Here’s what the critics are saying, and they aren’t being particularly kind:

Chicago Tribune: “If you can forget any knee-jerk reaction to the idea of the show, and forgive historical inaccuracies and a bit of hypocrisy, you might enjoy its mob mystery and an intriguing gay subplot, not to mention the fabulous Laura Benanti — and Eddie Cibrian’s dimples.”

The Hollywood Reporter:The Playboy Club is one of two new dramas (ABC’s Pan Am being the other) that tries to cash in on the retro feel of Mad Men but has neither the ambition, writing nor acting to make such a comparison anything more than a chuckle-heavy notion.” …

“The whole thing quickly becomes hokey and a grind. Blame goes consistently to the writing, from one Bunny reiterating how awesome Nick is — up to and including the rumor that he has a big penis — to another Bunny scolding an allegedly prudish married Bunny by saying she waves her wedding ring around ‘like a man could get electrocuted if he so much as glances in the region of your kitty cat.'”

Reuters: “The musical touches are just the kind of unselfconscious goofiness the show could use more of — they feel as tacked on as the performances at the Boar’s Nest that used to end episodes of the Dukes of Hazzard. And that’s fun.

“The show will improve if it can loosen up to be a little more Dukes of Hazzard and a little less Mad Men: First, because Daisy never monologued about Appalachian poverty to make up for those shorts. And second, because it poses no threat whatsoever to Mad Men in terms of storytelling, social commentary, or acting. (Then again, few shows do.)”

The Playboy Club does do a good job of swiping some aesthetics from Mad Men, but the Mad Men cast still wear better clothes — and slightly more of them.”

NPR: “I don’t want to spend more attention on this particular pilot than it deserves, to be candid. It’s splashy, it’s heavily promoted, and it’s just completely uninteresting. Don’t misunderstand: I’m not angry at The Playboy Club for not being expertly written and acted. I like a good, frothy nighttime soap. There are a couple of shows that may turn out to be just that kind of thing this fall. But this isn’t particularly soapy, it isn’t sexy, it isn’t fun. It’s just uninspiring actors going through the motions, weak and watery dialogue (‘You’re selling something people want — and it sure ain’t cigarettes!’), and cliched plot elements (bitter aging beauty resents younger beauty, good man struggles to escape criminal ties, and so forth).”

“You’ve seen this all before, done better. You’ll see it done better again. As a matter of fact, you’ll see it done better this week. There’s absolutely no reason to sit through The Playboy Club, revisions or no revisions. It’s one thing to be all in good fun, but this is all in no fun.”

NY Daily News: “The show itself, meanwhile, periodically tries to convince us the Playboy Club was really helping women empower themselves by stuffing them into unwearable outfits. It also tries to convey the broader sense of freedom and possibility that was starting to waft through the air in those years, even as the accordant sense of change felt unsettling.”

“So we’ve got this murder mystery weaving in and out, and the bunnies are struggling with their love lives, and we keep hearing well-chosen period music like “Playboy” and “Shake a Tail Feather,” and the gay rights group the Mattachine Society is meeting, and the sobering truth is that sometimes when you mix too many colors, you don’t get a brighter rainbow. You get dark gray. Or, in this case, a supersize soap opera.”

Not that The Playboy Club seems to notice. ‘The world was changing,’ a Hefner character intones in voice-over, ‘and we were the ones changing it — one bunny at a time.’ Someone ought to get a Best Supporting Actor Emmy for reading that line with a straight face.”

What do you think? Will you try this new TV series? Do you think it’s worthwhile or should it be quickly cancelled instead?

Canceled and renewed TV show

17 Comments · Read them below or add one

  1. Bethany says

    I have nothing against Playboy, Hugh Heffner, or whatever. I guess as far as such mags go, it is one of the higher class ones out there. That being said, I have no plans to watch the show. The basic premise doesn’t speak to me in any way. Of course this means that the show will probably run for the next 15 years, with each year a promise that it will be their last. Because that is how things seem to work these days.

    Between having 3 DVRs in my home, all doubling for about 10 hours a day, and the latest updates to Xfinity OnDemand providing many shows I had to miss otherwise, I watch practically every show on the air that is worth watching. I use FF but if I see an ad I have not seen a million times, I actually do stop, and sometimes rewind to catch it. The fact that the networks choose to run shows like this to open up my schedule so I don’t have to record or ever tune into the network’s alternative showings is kind of nice. Now I will have more DVR room, and more time to enjoy the shows that are actually worth my time.

  2. tom says

    It’s a keeper. I will watch. I could say something derogatory about the critics. The more they hate it. The more I want it. This was obviously not going to be for the ‘politically correct’ crowd. I do expect diversity. I do expect sexiness. I do expect that the stories will be in the back drop of Kennedy, organized crime, Roe v Wade, civil rights and the Cold War. A little hint… some playboy clubs were used by American and Soviet intermediates, it was considered neutral territory.

  3. Craig says

    The pilot was poor. I can’t imagine ratings going forward will allow the show to stay on the air for long, and that is a good thing.

  4. Ro says

    looked foward to remembering the excitement, fun and pure class our friends and I experienced at the PB Club.
    Maybe the writers should speak with actual club visitors,owners or ex-bunnies to get the
    very real ambience of the place.Looking forward to hopefully truly exciting
    stories and characters who feel like “the real thing” .

Leave a Comment

Your comment may need approval from a moderator before it appears. We review comments to weed out spam, duplicate postings and personal attacks. We welcome constructive discussion.