Having survived the halls of Glynn Ellen High as a student, Becky Freeley (Judy Greer) returns in her new role as guidance counselor. She believes life as an adult in her alma mater will be completely different until she learns that the new-hire in the English department is knock-out Lisa Germain (Brooke Burns), Becky’s former nemesis. Making matters worse is the fact that Lisa pursues Becky’s crush, dreamy shop teacher Tim O’Malley (Kristoffer Polaha). As Becky battles Lisa for Tim’s attention, she realizes that her adult life isn’t really that different after all.