Could Parks and Recreation have more in common with Stranger Things than just its Indiana setting? Recently, Parks and Rec star Ben Schwartz and Stranger Things‘ Joe Keery met to discuss an ongoing fan theory about their two characters, EW reports.

Since Stranger Things premiered on Netflix this summer, fans have theorized (half-jokingly) that Steve (Keery) must be the father of Jean-Ralphio (Schwartz) from Parks and Rec due to the two actors’ resemblance.

On a recent episode of The Late Late Show with James Corden, the two sat down to “disprove” the connection. Check out the full interview below:

What do you think? Are you a fan of Stranger Things and Parks and Rec? Would you like to see Schwartz on the Netflix series?