Eight months after HBO picked up Tell Me You Love Me for a second year, the TV series hasn’t returned. Now, apparently, it never will. What happened?
The sexually-explicit drama debuted on September 9, 2007 and revolves around three couples, each with their own set of intimacy problems. They seek help from Dr. May Foster (Jane Alexander), an analyst with relationship issues of her own. The series’ ensemble cast includes Michelle Borth, Tim DeKay, Luke Kirby, Adam Scott, David Selby, Katharine Towne, Sonya Walger, and Ally Walker. The tenth episode aired on November 10, 2007.
The ratings for the show’s first season weren’t great but HBO renewed Tell Me for another season after just four episodes had aired. Despite the renewal, the show didn’t return to production. Now, it appears that the reason for the stall was that creator/executive producer Cynthia Mort couldn’t figure out what should come next.
In a written statement, she said, “Given the considerable amount of time that has passed and despite the best efforts of everyone involved, we were unable to find the direction of the show for the second season. There are so many other stories to tell and many other ways to tell them. I look forward to doing that with HBO in the future.”
The cancellation decision was apparently a mutual decision. HBO has a development deal with Mort and intends to continue working with her. Michael Lombardo, HBO’s West Coast president, said, “We really feel Cynthia has an important voice that belongs on HBO and we look forward to the next show she will create for us.” Stay tuned! 
This is absolutely disheartening. My wife and I have waited…..and waited for the return of this fresh, bold and REAL illustration of intimacy problems in various stages of couples’ relationships. The show offered “water cooler” chat for dating/attached/engaged/married couples – hopefully, to detour any potential problems that arise. I HONESTLY can’t believe the “inability to decide on the ultimate direction of the next season” as the TRUE reason for the Tell Me’s demise. Any writer/creator has already alternate story lines before the original storyline is published/written/adapted for screen. The three storylines had so much run for expanding – it was… Read more »
i was looking forward to the second season. that’s really disappointing. not sure i will watch another show done by hort because who knows if she will know how to continue it.
I enjoyed this show… I hoped it would come back, but gave up after a while. It was very real and I enjoyed witnessing the emotions and psychology behind the couples’ lives.
I’m addicted to True Blood now, so I have moved on 🙂
im glad they cancelled this garbage. who wants to watch ugly people having sex over and over… BLAH. boring. good job HBO(aka the ***** channel)!!
Too bad, this was a great show. Not much on HBO since Sopranos and Six Feet Under are gone.
OHH COME ON!!! i was waiting and waiting!!! now this crap! that show was so good. it was more of a reality show then anything else out there. it was real people and real problems. there arent any other shows like it…they should hurry up and firgure out which way they want the show to go!. like seriously…and why even put the first season on dvd? there aint gunna be no collection!!!
THAT SUCKS! I’ve been waiting for it to come back on…… my husband and I loved watching it together.
Very dissapointed, thought it was a great show for couples to watch together as well as conversation starter. Great, young, unique show, best for me since Sopranos 🙁
I really liked the show. It was a honest portrayal of how tough relationships are and how much they are worth fighting for. It is really an adult show in a tv climate where everything is made for a teen demographic that was refreshing. When do you ever see an elderly couple in love and actually having sex. Anyway boo HBO for canceling such a great show
I am so sick of HBO, this is just like Big Love and Entourage everyone waited 2 years for season 3 and they only showed what? 6-7 episodes? So now what?, wait another 2 years? How do you expect people to get into a series or have a successful series when you yourself as a company can not come up with a reasonable amount of time in between seasons to keep the viewers interested. I am so upset they cancelled this show and didn’t even have the nerve to post it on their website or announce it. I’m about to… Read more »
I guess i am really slow at finding out when shows arn’t coming back. You never hear anything. You have to go searching on the internet to find the gossip. Why would you write a show with only 1 season in mind? I find it pathetic that the writer couldn’t decide which direction the show should go in. There is no other show on TV that gave such an honest look at life. I am very dissappointed. Yet again another show i enjoyed and now it has been cancelled. People are going to stop watching new shows all together when… Read more »
I am so so so so upset. I got hooked on this when it first came on. My partner and I called out of work so that we could watch all of the episodes. We have been waiting and waiting for the second season. Everynight, I check the on-demand listings, EVERYNIGHT!!!!!! Ugh! I mean, two years now. Are you kidding?!?!?!?!?!?! What a ****** thing to do! I AM PISSSSSSSSEEEEEEDDDDDD!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
I am extremely dissappointed that the show is not returning. My sister peaked my interest in the show and I watched all of the episodes on demand. After the last episode – I was really looking forward to the second season and so was she. We were hooked and saw ourselves in each of the female characters. What a waste to be left hanging 😕
well, if this woman ever creates another show, i will NEVER watch it…i got into this show and i’m dissappointed it isn’t returning. she certainly gives a bad name to female leaders…indecisive…unable to deal…
Aww booo I was afraid of this when I didn’t hear a peep about the show coming back. Man so many awesome story lines are just left hanging now…very disappointing and yes other than some cool documentaries on HBO their series choices are sad. UGH!!