Whodunnit?: Cancel or Keep the ABC Mystery Series?

WHODUNNIT? cancel or keep?Since June, ABC has been airing a murder mystery reality series called Whodunnit?. Has the show been making a killing in the ratings? Should the network cancel or renew it for a second season?

Whodunnit? follows a group of 13 contestants who have been invited to stay in a Beverly Hills mansion. Guided by host/butler Giles (Gildart Jackson), they try to solve the “murders” of other contestants, uncover the killer’s identity, and survive long enough to ultimately win a $250,000 prize.

The show debuted on June 23rd to a 1.3 rating in the 18-49 demographic with 4.05 million total viewers. It wasn’t a very impressive start and the second episode’s ratings dropped more than 20%, to a 1.0 rating and 3.19 million viewers. The numbers have stayed at roughly those levels ever since.

The ratings are pretty lousy but the small audience has remained consistent and loyal. While ABC could justifiably cancel Whodunnit?, something tells me they may give it a second chance anyway.

The network sometimes decides to give struggling shows a bit more time. For example, they could have cancelled Shark Tank after one season but decided to stick with it instead. Their patience was rewarded and it’s grown into a hit show on Friday nights. Whodunnit? might be lucky as well.

But, what do you think? Should ABC renew Whodunnit? for a second season or should they cancel it instead? Have you been watching each week?

224 Comments · Read them below or add one

  1. eddie says

    ALFRED HITCHCOCK would be proud to see a show with this many twist and turns the farther along it goes until the suprize ending.
    EGAR ALLEN POE would also be interested in the show with as much blood and guts-murder and mayhem that it has.
    as two of my favorite authors would be, so am i. my family sat and watched every episode and we even went so far as to discuss the clues, write down who we thought was it in envelopes unti l the end. we laughed-looked, just as the game of CLUE, kept our, or some observations secret.
    keep what is good like this for bringing a family together with cell phones off and quility time together. so keep it. or wonder not WHODUNNIT but WHYDIDTHEY not watch our other shows.

  2. Vincent says

    Please let there be a season 2. Anthony Zuiker tweeted that his boss at ABC Reality got replaced (the head of ABC’s Reality programming), so that’s why Whodunnit is up in the air. Of course, it sounded like the outgoing person was receptive to a second season of Whodunnit.

    The show was great, especially as a summer show. Once I realized it wasn’t going to be The Mole or Murder In Small Town X (my initial hopes for the show), I grew to love it for what it was – Good campy fun.

    A lot of times with these shows, people who miss the first episode feel like they missed too many clues and won’t be able to figure out who the killer or mole is, so they never tune in. A second season gives the people who missed season one a chance to start fresh with a new murderer to find. The networks usually look at the first season ratings and think people aren’t interested, rather than realizing people want to start on day one. Then they cancel the show and never get to find out that new people would watch the second season.

  3. Tyler says

    If they dont renew this show, I am going to be very, very mad. The creator of the show made a book of it, along with a second book, so if they do do this second season, the book would probably be a reference. This show gave me Sundays to look forward to, along with my family. And I do agree with Randy Congdon about them changing up the finale, along with other things that they do with it, but this show does have a lot of potential for a second season. Even if the Second season isn’t as great as the first, I will defiantly not miss one episode of it. :)

  4. says

    only have 4 little words to say
    PLEASEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
    HAVEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
    AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
    SEASONNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN2

    • Rick says

      Yes! I can’t wait to watch Season Two of WHODUNNIT on –
      AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
      BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
      CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC !

  5. Rick says

    I am one of those ‘loyal’ fans of this wonderful show. Along with ‘What Would You Do?’, it is what keeps me scouring the tv guide for your innovative entertainment. And I am generally impressed. I couldn’t wait to tune in for every episode of ‘WhoDunnit?’ and I don’t do that with that many other shows. I love it because it is different from the usual fare and because it makes me smile, laugh, think, hope for or against a contestant’s survival, and to see if I can figure out the week’s ending. I have my daughter anxiously awaiting for the next round in 2014, ( HOPEFULLY! ). I’ sure that this will be a very popular show even though it got off to a slow start. I think I can tell a winner when I see one, and this show is just that. If, or should I say, when, you begin the next season, please do a bit more advertising. Also, I think some viewers may have gotten it confused with ‘What Would You Do?’ because of the similar title. In any event, thanks for delivering what I consider to be a top-rated endeavor.

  6. Judy says

    Loved the show. Didn’t want to miss an episode, so I made sure to tape it. All my family always watched it. I keep hoping they renew it.

  7. FallerWanderer says

    I might be a Disney girl at heart, but I loved Whodunnit. The graphics were realistic, the puzzles challenging. And Giles. Dear gosh, Giles.

  8. JTmom says

    Oh please oh please oh please let there be a second season. I had so much fun watching this show. My husband and I would go back and forth with who we thought “The Killer” was. My mother is a big fan of murder mysteries which has been instilled in me. It’s like a real life “Clue” game and I had a blast watching it and trying to concoct my own plan of how each horrific “murder” took place. Scream if you want a Season 2. Yay!!

  9. Ali says

    We hope you keep Whodunnit. Although it was a little slow once in a while, overall it was interesting. We never missed an episode. The actors were a little stiff before they had to be, but overall very enjoyable.

    • RDM says

      They’re not even actors.. They’re real people. I’ve been watching Adrianna Iwasinski on news 9 here in OKC for years

  10. Sydney says

    I loved Whodunnit me and my friend watched it every Sunday we kept on guessing until the end. We were always on the edge of our seat. please let season 2 to begin. I loved it!!!!!

    • Randy Congdon says

      I loved the show, but they will have to change the way they do the finale if the decide to renew. Otherwise fans will know what to expect. The suspense worked the first time, and if the writers do their job creatively as they did this past season, my wife and I will stay hooked. By the way, neither of us were even close on the identity of “THE KILLER” until the first few minutes of the finale. We loved the mystery. Please keep this show.

Leave a Comment

Your comment may need approval from a moderator before it appears. We review comments to weed out spam, duplicate postings and personal attacks. We welcome constructive discussion.