The Goode Family and Surviving Suburbia: ABC Prez Says Sitcoms Cancelled

The Goode FamilyAt today’s Television Critic’s Association summer press tour, ABC Entertainment President Steve McPherson conceded that two of the network’s freshman sitcoms wouldn’t be coming back for second seasons.

The Goode Family is an animated series from King of the Hill’s Mike Judge, David Krinsky, and John Altschuler. Featuring the voice talents of Judge, Brian Doyle Murray, Dave Herman, Linda Cardellini, and Nancy Carell, the sitcom follows a working-class family who, despite their best efforts, find it difficult to live politically-correct lives.

Surviving Suburbia stars Bob Saget as a father who lives in a typical suburban household but can’t seem to find much that makes him happy. Castmembers of the sitcom also include Cynthia Stevenson, Jared Kusnitz, G. Hannelius, Jere Burns, Dan Cortese, Lorna Scott, and Lyndsey Jolly.

Both series have had disappointing runs on ABC. Goode Family debuted to a disappointing 3.93 million viewers and a 1.6/5 in the 18-49 demo. The network shifted it to Friday nights after three airings and the numbers nosedived to a series low of just 1.09 million and a 0.3/1.

Which sitcom was better?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Meanwhile, Surviving Suburbia brought in solid numbers when it followed popular Dancing with the Stars. The show’s debut attracted 12.16 million viewers and a 3.2/8 rating/share. Once Dancing with the Stars was over however, the sitcom’s audience declined considerably — to a terrible 2.83 million and a 1.0/3. The network shifted Saget and company to Friday nights and the numbers have dipped to 2.23 million and a 0.5/2 in the 18-49 demographic.

Last night marked the season finales of both series. While few expected that ABC would give either a sophomore run, it’s rare for a network executive to actually admit when shows are finished. According to The Futon Critic, McPherson laid the shows to rest today, saying that neither would be back.

What do you think? Are you disappointed that neither will be returning or, should ABC have pulled them long ago?

Canceled and renewed TV show

21 Comments · Read them below or add one

  1. DD says

    ABC is just not a good channel for an animated show. Judge needs to either go back to Fox, or work up a deal to do something on Comedy Central or Cartoon Network’s Adult Swim.

  2. sarah says

    That sucks, surviving suburbia was hilarious! Seinfeld didn’t do so hot in the ratings its first year, and it came back to be one of the most popular tv shows on tv. I was hoping the same thing would happen with surviving suburbia. :(

  3. Mark says

    I loved THE GOODE FAMILY. I want more!!!!!!! Please dont give up, it is an amazing animated show. Be back, I expect to see more funny stories of eco-crazed family! Sometimes I see myself in them when I go to my eco-store, haha..

Leave a Comment

Your comment may need approval from a moderator before it appears. We review comments to weed out spam, duplicate postings and personal attacks. We welcome constructive discussion.