We’ve now completed our sitcom tournament and you, our readers, have come up with a winner.
The voting started with a selection of more than 200 beloved comedies. From there, we paired the candidates down to 58 choices. Even then, things were starting to get difficult.
In round three, things got really tough though as we pitted legendary shows against one another — I Love Lucy vs. The Honeymooners; The Dick Van Dyke Show vs The Andy Griffith Show; M*A*S*H vs All in the Family; The Cosby Show vs Cheers; Seinfeld vs Friends; and Everybody Loves Raymond vs The Big Bang Theory. Any of them could easily have come out as the big winner.
In round four, the victors of round three were paired off. In the end, I Love Lucy won over The Andy Griffith Show and Seinfeld beat Everybody Loves Raymond. Cheers and M*A*S*H were so close that we moved them both to the final round. We also introduced a wildcard category in which shows that had been eliminated in round three were given a second chance. Friends was the easy victor.
And then, in the final round, it came down to just five challengers — Cheers, Friends, I Love Lucy, M*A*S*H, and Seinfeld. After more than 27,000 tournament votes, we now have our winners.
Despite being beaten by Seinfeld in round three, Friends has won the title. You, our readers, believe that the gang at Central Perk have the best sitcom in history. Not too far behind them is all-time classic I Love Lucy, a show that many would have thought would have won. And then, right behind Lucy, is the little show from the 1990s, Seinfeld.
Thanks to everyone who voted and left their feedback! We’re planning on doing another tournament soon!
What do you think of the winners? Are you surprised? Any suggestions for future tournaments?
Newer and/or Related Articles
-
The Andy Griffith Show, Matlock: Griffith Dies at 86
Jul 3, 2012 -
I Love Lucy: Doris Singleton Dies; Farewell Carolyn Appleby
Jun 27, 2012 -
I Love Lucy: The Artist Who’s Drawn Lucy Hundreds of Times
Feb 10, 2012 -
I Love Lucy: Google Celebrates Lucille Ball’s 100th Birthday
Aug 6, 2011 -
Everybody Loves Raymond: A Russian Version and a Documentary
Nov 8, 2010 -
The Andy Griffith Show: Zach Galifiankis Influenced by Classic Theme Performer
Nov 5, 2010 -
Round Five: What’s the Best Sitcom in TV History — Final Five!
May 11, 2010 -
Round Four: What’s the Best Sitcom in TV History?
May 5, 2010 -
Round Three: What’s the Best Sitcom in TV History?
Apr 27, 2010 -
Round Two: What’s the Best Sitcom in TV History?
Apr 20, 2010 -
Lost: Want to Advertise on the Last Episode?
Mar 30, 2010 -
Preliminary Round: What’s the Best Sitcom in TV History?
Mar 15, 2010 -
The Andy Griffith Show: TV Land Statue Defaced
Feb 25, 2010 -
Round One: What Top TV Show Should Be Cancelled?
Jan 19, 2010 -
Josh Groban Sings a Tribute to TV Show Theme Songs — What’d They Miss?
Sep 22, 2008 -
Everybody Loves Raymond
Oct 23, 2007 -
Where Are They Now? Green Room Chatter for October 19, 2007
Oct 19, 2007 -
I Love Lucy: Actor Charles Lane Leaves a Long Career
Jul 10, 2007
{ 49 comments… read them below or add one }
← Previous Comments
Friends? get out of town! It’s not even in the same league as MASH, Cheers and Seinfeld.
Hands down, Friends….
I agree that the “best of all time” title should be reserved for shows that have stood the test of time. I think that M*A*S*H* should have won the title. While I love “I love lucy” I think that MASH’s ability to stay so popular after over 30 years off the air coupled with the fact that the final episode drew so may viewers, (almost 1/2 of the US population in 1983) more than qualifies it as the best of all time. The show still remains on the air in over 100 countries and in at least that many languages.
I Love Lucy, Friends, The Simpsons (I know it is not a sitcom but it has such similar qualities to one, Plus the first fifteen seasons were hilarious), Cheers and M*A*S*H. This is my list, but I am not at all surprised Friends won, not only is it extremely funny but the characters were so relatable that you found yourself in the show cutting of Chandlers toe or running away from satin (the dog) or “being on a break”. Great choice, and for those who do not think so well you are entitled to your opinion but please do not try to repress our opinion.
Like it or not, I don’t care, but FRIENDS is the best sitcom of all time. Haters can go jump in a pool.
IN THE ERA OF TELEVISION, WITH THE OUTSTANDING ARTISTS AND TV SERIES, I CANNOT BELEIVE THAT FRIENDS COULD HAVE BEAT OUT ALL OF THE BEST. THE ONLY THING THAT FRIENDS HAD AS THEIR ADVANTAGE WAS THEIR TIMESLOT. TAKEN OVER FROM CHEERS. I NEVER FOUND THEM INTERESTING OR FUNNY AT ALL. WHOEVER VOTED THEM IN AS THE BEST SITCOM OF ALL MUST HAVE BEEN THEM
V
I absolutely hated Friends–it has no business being voted the best or in the top 10 anywhere. Where is the Odd Couple, WKRP in all of this? By far better acted, better written and just plain better. I would put Friends somewhere behind Me and the Chimp or My Mother the Car!!!
I think its a tie between I Love Lucy and The Nanny. Both shows have me LOL….literally.
If I am down in the dumps, all I have to do is watch either of these shows and I forget about my troubles.
I think it is safe to say that one generation of viewers voted more than others. To me, Friends and Seinfeld are too young to earn a “best ever” award if it is based on sustainability and continuous syndication runs. Although I’m not a big fan of it, “I Love Lucy” should be the real winner as it is still on the air after all these decades. M*A*S*H certainly qualifies for the same reasons. Time will be the ultimate judge for Seinfeld and Friends. And measuring DVD sales and online viewing adds a whole new dimension to the criteria.
Seinfeld Hands Down is THE GREATEST tv sitcom to EVER hit the airwaves ! The 4 goofballs on that show have kept a nation (possibly THE WORLD) watching them over and over for more than a decade now after the show has stopped production of new material ! I can only hope that maybe one day to see a new episode or movie pop up with these four NYers REUNITED ! And when Jerry brings up the idea down at Monks , Elaine will push him in the chest (almost knocking him down) and scream GET OUT !
Seinfeld is clearly the TRUE victor overall…
Look, I think that all the older generation who think “I Love Lucy” is the clear winner need to really rethink this. I have always enjoyed watching Lucy, as have my parents who are part of your generation. Even they admit that while Lucy was hilarious, many sitcoms today are much smarter and funnier with greater wit than than Lucy’s writers could ever provide. You take Lucille Ball out of the show: You have no show. That is how good she was. She transcended the script she was given. The writing wasn’t necessarily great – she made it great. If there was a poll of the the funniest sitcom actor, she would definitely deserve to be number one of all time. I think we can agree on this. But her show really does not deserve this distinction, whether or not you find the modern comedy to be humorous. That being said, Friends doesn’t even belong in the Top 10 of all time. Oh, before I step off my soap box. You really can’t fault Friends for their jokes revolving around sex unless you also fault “I Love Lucy” for being so sexually repressed that their characters slept in separate beds. In closing, I just want to say that “I Love Lucy” was was arguably the best sitcom of its time.
← Previous Comments